Tasting Rum is More Than Fun - Beverage Testing Institute

Tasting Rum is More Than Fun

For many of us Rum is a drink first associated with fun; beach vacations with a Pina Colada or Daiquiri, a Hurricane at Mardi Gras, rum and cokes at a college party, or Mai Tais and Painkillers keeping the winter blues away while you dream of beautiful Polynesian islands. Rum more than any other beverage is associated with fun.  But don’t let the fun fool you, in the finest examples, such as El Dorado 15 Year or Zacapa Centenario, rum is as fine a sipping spirit as Single Malt Scotch, Cognac, and Bourbon, with connoisseurs taking the spirit just as seriously. What rum lacks in reaching true premium status is the regulatory regiment of a single country enforcing production methods.

Imagine going to the store and having to ascertain if the Rittenhouse, Midleton, Eagle Rare, Yamazaki, or Lao Khao bottle next to the Macallan 12 was or was not the same kind of whisky. Lines of demarcation and order largely exist in the world of Whiskies, because of countries regulating regional categories. Those regulations over time lead to a global marketplace and public awareness that when you pick up a bottle of Weller 12 you don’t think the whiskey will taste like Laphroaig 10 Year. Now head down the Rum aisle and attempt to ascertain the differences between sugar cane column still distillate like Rhum J.M. or molasses-based column distillate from Havana Club. Is 21-year-old Fijian pot still from Holmes Cay or 10-year pot still from Mount Gay basically made the same way or totally differently? What is the difference between Worthy Park and Zaya when the retailer describes both as “rich and heavy” in style?

As rum becomes a more serious sipper with aficionados and collectors there is a temptation to homogenize to a categorical standard along the lines of Single Malt Scotch Whisky. Although these efforts towards truth in age statements, transparency in cask management and distillate source, and removal of flavoring and additives in Rum not marked as flavored or spiced are to be commended, one need only scan a few online message boards to wonder if the current call for “dry” Rum is sucking the fun out of the category. Admittedly some Rums are so heavily back sweetened as to border being a cordial and we are all aware that sugar has long been used to cover up flaws in distillate, as well as bitterness and tannins picked up in oak maturation. Nonetheless, sugar—whether direct from the fields, processed and returned as molasses or used to back-sweeten—is the base ingredient of Rum and some degree of sweetness is an inextricable part of the spirit, character, and fun of Rum.

History shows that Rum has always been sweetened. Sugar hides flaws of lower quality products and obscures complexity, intensity, and nuance in high quality products, but when blended and balanced delicately can add a rounder texture, counteract the perception of acid and alcohol, and accentuate natural fruit flavors. Some of the finest wines in the world like Chateau d’Yquem, Egon Müller’s Riesling, or Tokaji Essesncia rely on sugar. Many Champagne house tête de cuvée also include a dash of sugar to balance the acidity. The ability to include a little sugar should not be seen as bad in and of itself. Sugar used to excess or added with the ability to also mix in vanilla, cinnamon, and other flavors, as is done in various countries without any disclosure, while other producers choose to be transparent or are required to by national law to do so, is the problem and essentially like doping in international sports. The long-term solution, like sports, is regulation such as we see with Martinique AOC Rhum and are beginning to see with efforts from Richard Seale of Four Square distillery, Mount Gay, and Diplomatico in creating Rum Designations of Controlled Origins (DOC), and others testing new categorical constraints.

Island dreams of establishing national regulations from a year-round BTI lab in Fiji aside, the team at Beverage Testing Institute are well qualified to unravel the testing portion of this Gordian Knot (and blind no less!) Rum cannot be simplified down to pot still, column still, or blended, nor broken down to cane juice, grade A, B, and black strap molasses. The French, Spanish, or English colonial traditions of a place also only paint a partial picture that can often obscure much like the use or exclusion of back sweetening. Is there a funky characteristic arising from the use of natural yeast, dunder pits, or a variety of casks? Each of these aspects, and many more, must be understood and placed in context without the benefit of standardized categories (tasting XO Cognac seems so simple in comparison) to contextualize and analyze a Rum. A complex situation to be sure, but there too is part of the fun of Rum. With or without sugar or cask aging, a rum’s story is told by the quality of distillate, devoid of flaws, and then blended and balanced to please the senses. So let’s get to tasting and let the tropical vacation begin.

Sherry, Sherry in the Cask. Who is the Fairest You Might Ask?

A tippling tour through the wonderland of Sherry-finished whiskies For many lovers of fine Whiskies or luxury spirits of any type, there are few things better than a well-aged Scotch matured in Sherr...

Corks Versus Screw Caps: Which Is Better?

A recent report from Wine.com that correlated high-quality wines with cork closures got me thinking about corks and screw caps. Since April is Earth Month, it’s a good time to explore natural co...

Celebrating Lagers for King Gambrinus Day

Today is King Gambrinus’ birthday – and rather than drink an entire cask of beer, as he so cleverly once did to more easily win a barrel lifting contest, let us celebrate this mythological personi...

BTI Partners with Michigan Wine Collaborative for 2023 Governor’s Cup

The Beverage Testing Institute is working with the Michigan Wine Collaborative to evaluate several hundred samples with results to be announced in person this summer. Check out this article for mor...

A New Time for Amphora Wines to Shine

Amphora wines, which date back thousands of years are being rediscovered and embraced by restaurants, winemakers, and passionate wine drinkers. “Everything old is new again.” says Aldo Zaninotto, ...

"The consistency and broad consumer reach of BTI ratings and reviews really solidified the quality message of our artisan brand and helped us build a well-distributed and highly regarded specialty portfolio of beers."
Laurent-Xavier Gilbert,
VP Development at La Brasserie Unibroue
"The BTI rankings have an effect on what restaurants put on their wine lists, and ultimately on what you might be drinking."
Joe Gray,
Editor, Chicago Tribune
"BTI is still the outstanding tasting organization, uniquely independent. Keep up the good work!"
Jan Wells,
VP of Marketing, Cannon Wines
"Beverage Testing Institute is a professional operation with a professional approach. I like that they are committed to truly blind tastings and that their reviews are comprehensive and informative. We highlight the reviews in our tasting room and post them on social media; the consumer response is very positive. "
Edwin Richards,
Winemaker/Owner, Adastra
“Our BTI awards have helped us with our US distribution. Sales have increased form 0 cases to 250 cases in just a couple of months. We opened two new accounts in Seattle and New York.”
Eduardo Aguirre Victoria,
Terre de Vignerons
“[BTI's] Tastings.com is well known as a main reference for connoisseurs, experts and followers of spirits.”
Otto Flores,
Ron Barcelo
"We have used Tastings.com (BTI) for the last 5 years and couldn’t be happier. They always have great customer service and support! Not only do they have detailed professional reviews and tasting notes, the addition of the metallic stickers and shelf-talkers help us capture customers, and drive bottle sales. The trophies, medals, and printed awards are displayed as center pieces in our tasting room. Their website is easy to navigate and has great product information."
Mike Huffman,
Whidbey Island Distillery
“Our winery has had BTI rate our wines for a number of years. We use the bottle stickers and shelf talkers for both education and to enhance our marketing. We have had distributors request bottle stickers, and during wine pourings, we use the shelf talkers as a customer take away. We appreciate the information written by BTI since we find it to be concise, descriptive, informational, and a well rounded review of our wines.“
Janet Soderberg,
Alamira Wines, Vistaflores Estate
When we found out that our 20 year Pappy Van Winkle had been entered in BTI's 1997 World Spirits Championships and received their 99-point rating, that’s when we started getting calls from distributors around the country looking for our whiskey.

That was a benchmark moment for our business. Every time we received a high rating from BTI over the years, interest increased for our brand.

We owe a lot to the Beverage Testing Institute for our success.
Julian P. Van Winkle, III,
President, Old Rip Van Winkle Distillery
BTI has been our go-to partner for our alcohol awards program for years now, providing quality reviews of our wide selection of wines, beers and hard seltzers. The unique quarterly submission process allows our team to highlight new, trending and seasonal offerings and the staff at BTI is always responsive, collaborative and supportive to help us reach our goals.
Carrie Reitz,
Corporate Buying US, ALDI Inc.
The trust that consumers, major retailers, distributors and suppliers have for BTI makes their reviews and recommendations an invaluable complement and a huge asset to the success of Atlas’ bespoke label brands. I enthusiastically recommend their tools and services to anyone in the control or private label beverage program spaces.
Jim Cosma,
Atlas Imports

Brand Partners

Translate »